So Wil kinda says J-Man didn't make 3k a month, he was paid less, but implies he makes over 2k a month, maybe 3k as the main man ? 3k a month and living in CR would be pretty damn good, I think !
It would depend on the Mod and their duties, and connections.
All seem to do something else besides being a Mod, except for perhaps SS. He seems to be the exception that is closest to a career Mod, and has a lot of contests and stuff to tend to.
OMT seems to be a part-timer with little to do, thus he should get much less.
I have turned down $500 a month more than once to be a mod ( elsewhere). I know some guys get 1k a month at lesser sites. Some guys at even lesser sites get thrown a free account here and there as compensation.
It's a tough way to make a living. You could be forced to accept a paycut or quit ( Fishhead ?) at anytime. Unlikely to get a raise, no insurance or pension, no union, no real transferability of mod skills. It's not like you're a competent electrician, get pissed at your boss at one company... you can go work for another contractor.
Few options exist for a Mod to get another Mod job !
It's a very unstable "job" that can end at anytime.
Look at Mod turnover rates.